Cardiotocography (5% of outliers version#07)
Data set related to heart diseases. It describes 3 classes: normal, suspect, or pathological. Normal patients are treated as inliers and the remaining as outliers.
Download all data set variants used (8.8 MB). You can also access the original data. (CTG.xls)
- Normalized, without duplicates
- Normalized, duplicates
- Not normalized, without duplicates
- Not normalized, duplicates
Normalized, without duplicates
This version contains 21 attributes, 1734 objects, 86 outliers (4.96%)
Download raw algorithm results (15.0 MB) Download raw algorithm evaluation table (65.0 kB)
Best Parameters
The following table contains the best
(overall and per-method)
results for each method and evaluation measure (when the same score was achieved twice, only the smallest k is given).
The Maximum F1-Measure is complimentary in addition to the measures in the original publication.
Algorithm | k | P@n | Adj. P@n | AP | Adj. AP | Max-F1 | Adj. MF1 | ROC AUC |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
KNN | 1 | 0.29070 | 0.25368 | 0.24031 | 0.20067 | 0.30058 | 0.26408 | 0.73875 |
KNN | 96 | 0.26744 | 0.22921 | 0.26638 | 0.22809 | 0.31336 | 0.27753 | 0.77539 |
KNN | 99 | 0.26744 | 0.22921 | 0.26759 | 0.22937 | 0.31193 | 0.27602 | 0.77565 |
KNNW | 3 | 0.26744 | 0.22921 | 0.23448 | 0.19453 | 0.27368 | 0.23578 | 0.75229 |
KNNW | 5 | 0.26744 | 0.22921 | 0.25053 | 0.21142 | 0.30075 | 0.26426 | 0.74892 |
KNNW | 8 | 0.25581 | 0.21698 | 0.25750 | 0.21875 | 0.29197 | 0.25502 | 0.74686 |
KNNW | 100 | 0.25581 | 0.21698 | 0.25597 | 0.21714 | 0.28682 | 0.24960 | 0.76620 |
LOF | 9 | 0.26744 | 0.22921 | 0.20625 | 0.16483 | 0.27488 | 0.23704 | 0.72109 |
LOF | 11 | 0.26744 | 0.22921 | 0.21132 | 0.17016 | 0.30769 | 0.27156 | 0.73932 |
LOF | 20 | 0.24419 | 0.20474 | 0.23744 | 0.19764 | 0.29457 | 0.25776 | 0.75726 |
LOF | 100 | 0.23256 | 0.19251 | 0.20833 | 0.16702 | 0.24299 | 0.20349 | 0.78994 |
SimplifiedLOF | 19 | 0.30233 | 0.26592 | 0.24083 | 0.20121 | 0.31902 | 0.28348 | 0.75111 |
SimplifiedLOF | 20 | 0.31395 | 0.27815 | 0.23951 | 0.19983 | 0.31395 | 0.27815 | 0.75202 |
SimplifiedLOF | 32 | 0.26744 | 0.22921 | 0.24541 | 0.20603 | 0.29457 | 0.25776 | 0.75132 |
SimplifiedLOF | 100 | 0.24419 | 0.20474 | 0.21002 | 0.16880 | 0.26556 | 0.22723 | 0.77532 |
LoOP | 16 | 0.26744 | 0.22921 | 0.20630 | 0.16488 | 0.30769 | 0.27156 | 0.73755 |
LoOP | 17 | 0.29070 | 0.25368 | 0.21002 | 0.16879 | 0.30058 | 0.26408 | 0.73718 |
LoOP | 34 | 0.25581 | 0.21698 | 0.22511 | 0.18467 | 0.28571 | 0.24844 | 0.74388 |
LoOP | 100 | 0.23256 | 0.19251 | 0.20268 | 0.16107 | 0.28571 | 0.24844 | 0.76668 |
LDOF | 35 | 0.24419 | 0.20474 | 0.20622 | 0.16480 | 0.27941 | 0.24181 | 0.70140 |
LDOF | 38 | 0.26744 | 0.22921 | 0.20499 | 0.16351 | 0.27500 | 0.23717 | 0.70267 |
LDOF | 49 | 0.26744 | 0.22921 | 0.19559 | 0.15361 | 0.30345 | 0.26710 | 0.69815 |
LDOF | 100 | 0.23256 | 0.19251 | 0.18628 | 0.14382 | 0.26178 | 0.22326 | 0.73272 |
ODIN | 80 | 0.26578 | 0.22747 | 0.17245 | 0.12926 | 0.27273 | 0.23477 | 0.76157 |
ODIN | 100 | 0.24564 | 0.20627 | 0.17884 | 0.13599 | 0.25610 | 0.21728 | 0.76987 |
FastABOD | 36 | 0.26744 | 0.22921 | 0.19952 | 0.15775 | 0.26901 | 0.23086 | 0.80106 |
FastABOD | 37 | 0.26744 | 0.22921 | 0.19992 | 0.15817 | 0.27381 | 0.23591 | 0.80165 |
FastABOD | 100 | 0.25581 | 0.21698 | 0.20549 | 0.16402 | 0.26943 | 0.23131 | 0.80988 |
KDEOS | 86 | 0.19767 | 0.15581 | 0.12701 | 0.08146 | 0.20155 | 0.15988 | 0.72547 |
KDEOS | 89 | 0.18605 | 0.14357 | 0.12750 | 0.08197 | 0.20968 | 0.16843 | 0.72810 |
KDEOS | 93 | 0.18605 | 0.14357 | 0.12520 | 0.07955 | 0.21607 | 0.17516 | 0.73058 |
KDEOS | 99 | 0.18605 | 0.14357 | 0.12082 | 0.07494 | 0.20974 | 0.16850 | 0.73166 |
LDF | 6 | 0.25581 | 0.21698 | 0.25794 | 0.21921 | 0.28070 | 0.24317 | 0.68599 |
LDF | 86 | 0.32558 | 0.29039 | 0.23273 | 0.19269 | 0.34247 | 0.30815 | 0.77607 |
LDF | 98 | 0.31395 | 0.27815 | 0.25091 | 0.21181 | 0.34899 | 0.31502 | 0.78531 |
LDF | 100 | 0.31395 | 0.27815 | 0.25442 | 0.21551 | 0.34483 | 0.31064 | 0.78680 |
INFLO | 21 | 0.26744 | 0.22921 | 0.21325 | 0.17219 | 0.28931 | 0.25222 | 0.75925 |
INFLO | 29 | 0.27907 | 0.24145 | 0.20641 | 0.16500 | 0.27933 | 0.24172 | 0.74621 |
INFLO | 96 | 0.24419 | 0.20474 | 0.20565 | 0.16420 | 0.26852 | 0.23035 | 0.78729 |
COF | 18 | 0.27907 | 0.24145 | 0.28275 | 0.24532 | 0.31034 | 0.27436 | 0.70683 |
COF | 36 | 0.31395 | 0.27815 | 0.26368 | 0.22525 | 0.31395 | 0.27815 | 0.74829 |
COF | 49 | 0.30233 | 0.26592 | 0.24840 | 0.20918 | 0.33766 | 0.30310 | 0.74945 |
COF | 60 | 0.26744 | 0.22921 | 0.24208 | 0.20253 | 0.29487 | 0.25808 | 0.77580 |
Plots
Normalized, duplicates
This version contains 21 attributes, 1742 objects, 87 outliers (4.99%)
Download raw algorithm results (15.1 MB) Download raw algorithm evaluation table (67.6 kB)
Best Parameters
The following table contains the best
(overall and per-method)
results for each method and evaluation measure (when the same score was achieved twice, only the smallest k is given).
The Maximum F1-Measure is complimentary in addition to the measures in the original publication.
Algorithm | k | P@n | Adj. P@n | AP | Adj. AP | Max-F1 | Adj. MF1 | ROC AUC |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
KNN | 88 | 0.35632 | 0.32248 | 0.30604 | 0.26956 | 0.36364 | 0.33018 | 0.75228 |
KNN | 90 | 0.35632 | 0.32248 | 0.30638 | 0.26992 | 0.36571 | 0.33237 | 0.75166 |
KNN | 99 | 0.34483 | 0.31039 | 0.30828 | 0.27191 | 0.36158 | 0.32802 | 0.75446 |
KNNW | 2 | 0.32184 | 0.28619 | 0.26726 | 0.22875 | 0.34021 | 0.30552 | 0.74282 |
KNNW | 3 | 0.34483 | 0.31039 | 0.27909 | 0.24119 | 0.35897 | 0.32528 | 0.73566 |
KNNW | 4 | 0.33333 | 0.29829 | 0.28195 | 0.24420 | 0.36000 | 0.32636 | 0.72747 |
KNNW | 100 | 0.31034 | 0.27409 | 0.28402 | 0.24638 | 0.32520 | 0.28973 | 0.74201 |
LOF | 7 | 0.32184 | 0.28619 | 0.18854 | 0.14589 | 0.32558 | 0.29013 | 0.72532 |
LOF | 100 | 0.25287 | 0.21360 | 0.21837 | 0.17728 | 0.26829 | 0.22983 | 0.77592 |
SimplifiedLOF | 10 | 0.33333 | 0.29829 | 0.22968 | 0.18919 | 0.33333 | 0.29829 | 0.74469 |
SimplifiedLOF | 13 | 0.31034 | 0.27409 | 0.23773 | 0.19766 | 0.35122 | 0.31711 | 0.75159 |
SimplifiedLOF | 14 | 0.32184 | 0.28619 | 0.23159 | 0.19120 | 0.36620 | 0.33288 | 0.75593 |
SimplifiedLOF | 98 | 0.27586 | 0.23780 | 0.20576 | 0.16401 | 0.28743 | 0.24997 | 0.76354 |
LoOP | 11 | 0.29885 | 0.26199 | 0.19443 | 0.15208 | 0.32632 | 0.29090 | 0.73560 |
LoOP | 12 | 0.31034 | 0.27409 | 0.19882 | 0.15670 | 0.32000 | 0.28425 | 0.73594 |
LoOP | 98 | 0.26437 | 0.22570 | 0.19109 | 0.14856 | 0.26816 | 0.22968 | 0.75234 |
LDOF | 14 | 0.24138 | 0.20150 | 0.18845 | 0.14578 | 0.27468 | 0.23655 | 0.71820 |
LDOF | 19 | 0.25287 | 0.21360 | 0.18135 | 0.13831 | 0.27473 | 0.23660 | 0.72412 |
LDOF | 21 | 0.21839 | 0.17730 | 0.16342 | 0.11944 | 0.28000 | 0.24215 | 0.72803 |
LDOF | 95 | 0.20690 | 0.16520 | 0.17812 | 0.13491 | 0.24793 | 0.20840 | 0.74185 |
ODIN | 71 | 0.22989 | 0.18940 | 0.13901 | 0.09375 | 0.22989 | 0.18940 | 0.73752 |
ODIN | 98 | 0.20690 | 0.16520 | 0.15497 | 0.11055 | 0.23602 | 0.19586 | 0.74845 |
ODIN | 100 | 0.20920 | 0.16762 | 0.15592 | 0.11155 | 0.23529 | 0.19510 | 0.74962 |
FastABOD | 4 | 0.28736 | 0.24989 | 0.20050 | 0.15848 | 0.31429 | 0.27824 | 0.77239 |
FastABOD | 49 | 0.32184 | 0.28619 | 0.22104 | 0.18009 | 0.32298 | 0.28739 | 0.76100 |
FastABOD | 98 | 0.29885 | 0.26199 | 0.22267 | 0.18181 | 0.32990 | 0.29467 | 0.76363 |
FastABOD | 100 | 0.29885 | 0.26199 | 0.22281 | 0.18196 | 0.32990 | 0.29467 | 0.76381 |
KDEOS | 15 | 0.14943 | 0.10471 | 0.12808 | 0.08224 | 0.23622 | 0.19607 | 0.70100 |
KDEOS | 17 | 0.17241 | 0.12891 | 0.12700 | 0.08111 | 0.21296 | 0.17159 | 0.69591 |
KDEOS | 100 | 0.08046 | 0.03212 | 0.09053 | 0.04272 | 0.18538 | 0.14256 | 0.71371 |
LDF | 76 | 0.34483 | 0.31039 | 0.25968 | 0.22076 | 0.34483 | 0.31039 | 0.76001 |
LDF | 99 | 0.34483 | 0.31039 | 0.30135 | 0.26462 | 0.37500 | 0.34215 | 0.76797 |
LDF | 100 | 0.34483 | 0.31039 | 0.30248 | 0.26581 | 0.37267 | 0.33969 | 0.76736 |
INFLO | 8 | 0.24138 | 0.20150 | 0.16384 | 0.11988 | 0.28235 | 0.24463 | 0.71941 |
INFLO | 98 | 0.24138 | 0.20150 | 0.20215 | 0.16021 | 0.26866 | 0.23021 | 0.76299 |
INFLO | 100 | 0.24138 | 0.20150 | 0.20264 | 0.16072 | 0.26977 | 0.23138 | 0.76218 |
COF | 15 | 0.33333 | 0.29829 | 0.32195 | 0.28631 | 0.37662 | 0.34385 | 0.75468 |
COF | 17 | 0.39080 | 0.35878 | 0.30231 | 0.26563 | 0.39521 | 0.36342 | 0.74267 |
Plots
Not normalized, without duplicates
This version contains 21 attributes, 1734 objects, 86 outliers (4.96%)
Download raw algorithm results (15.0 MB) Download raw algorithm evaluation table (65.8 kB)
Best Parameters
The following table contains the best
(overall and per-method)
results for each method and evaluation measure (when the same score was achieved twice, only the smallest k is given).
The Maximum F1-Measure is complimentary in addition to the measures in the original publication.
Algorithm | k | P@n | Adj. P@n | AP | Adj. AP | Max-F1 | Adj. MF1 | ROC AUC |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
KNN | 1 | 0.24419 | 0.20474 | 0.17267 | 0.12949 | 0.26721 | 0.22897 | 0.78221 |
KNN | 98 | 0.19767 | 0.15581 | 0.14053 | 0.09568 | 0.26766 | 0.22944 | 0.76443 |
KNNW | 1 | 0.22093 | 0.18027 | 0.19137 | 0.14917 | 0.26852 | 0.23035 | 0.79202 |
KNNW | 2 | 0.23256 | 0.19251 | 0.19130 | 0.14909 | 0.27149 | 0.23348 | 0.80075 |
LOF | 6 | 0.24419 | 0.20474 | 0.15123 | 0.10694 | 0.25556 | 0.21671 | 0.68664 |
LOF | 8 | 0.24419 | 0.20474 | 0.16606 | 0.12254 | 0.27397 | 0.23609 | 0.71220 |
LOF | 9 | 0.23256 | 0.19251 | 0.17386 | 0.13074 | 0.26154 | 0.22300 | 0.71792 |
LOF | 99 | 0.17442 | 0.13134 | 0.15055 | 0.10623 | 0.26598 | 0.22768 | 0.80870 |
SimplifiedLOF | 10 | 0.25581 | 0.21698 | 0.18063 | 0.13787 | 0.26667 | 0.22840 | 0.71348 |
SimplifiedLOF | 11 | 0.24419 | 0.20474 | 0.19141 | 0.14921 | 0.28986 | 0.25280 | 0.72080 |
SimplifiedLOF | 12 | 0.24419 | 0.20474 | 0.19514 | 0.15314 | 0.27397 | 0.23609 | 0.72614 |
SimplifiedLOF | 95 | 0.17442 | 0.13134 | 0.14526 | 0.10066 | 0.25939 | 0.22074 | 0.78658 |
LoOP | 10 | 0.25581 | 0.21698 | 0.17455 | 0.13147 | 0.27273 | 0.23477 | 0.69392 |
LoOP | 11 | 0.24419 | 0.20474 | 0.17877 | 0.13591 | 0.28188 | 0.24440 | 0.70133 |
LoOP | 12 | 0.24419 | 0.20474 | 0.18260 | 0.13994 | 0.27419 | 0.23632 | 0.70919 |
LoOP | 89 | 0.17442 | 0.13134 | 0.14591 | 0.10134 | 0.25606 | 0.21723 | 0.77557 |
LDOF | 12 | 0.26744 | 0.22921 | 0.17245 | 0.12926 | 0.27059 | 0.23252 | 0.66148 |
LDOF | 100 | 0.17442 | 0.13134 | 0.15018 | 0.10583 | 0.24113 | 0.20153 | 0.77483 |
ODIN | 42 | 0.22020 | 0.17951 | 0.18517 | 0.14265 | 0.22951 | 0.18930 | 0.75147 |
ODIN | 43 | 0.22230 | 0.18171 | 0.18466 | 0.14211 | 0.23333 | 0.19333 | 0.75109 |
ODIN | 53 | 0.20085 | 0.15914 | 0.17789 | 0.13499 | 0.26984 | 0.23174 | 0.75950 |
ODIN | 100 | 0.17636 | 0.13338 | 0.18506 | 0.14253 | 0.26316 | 0.22471 | 0.76624 |
FastABOD | 5 | 0.22093 | 0.18027 | 0.18158 | 0.13888 | 0.26877 | 0.23062 | 0.80184 |
FastABOD | 10 | 0.24419 | 0.20474 | 0.17806 | 0.13517 | 0.25434 | 0.21542 | 0.80142 |
FastABOD | 66 | 0.20930 | 0.16804 | 0.17006 | 0.12674 | 0.27799 | 0.24031 | 0.80054 |
KDEOS | 90 | 0.18605 | 0.14357 | 0.15293 | 0.10873 | 0.22535 | 0.18493 | 0.76767 |
KDEOS | 93 | 0.16279 | 0.11910 | 0.15129 | 0.10700 | 0.23325 | 0.19324 | 0.76891 |
KDEOS | 100 | 0.17442 | 0.13134 | 0.16034 | 0.11653 | 0.24552 | 0.20615 | 0.76858 |
LDF | 76 | 0.23256 | 0.19251 | 0.15358 | 0.10941 | 0.27206 | 0.23407 | 0.80307 |
LDF | 92 | 0.22093 | 0.18027 | 0.16168 | 0.11793 | 0.29391 | 0.25706 | 0.81627 |
LDF | 100 | 0.22093 | 0.18027 | 0.16534 | 0.12179 | 0.29167 | 0.25470 | 0.82040 |
INFLO | 6 | 0.25581 | 0.21698 | 0.17027 | 0.12698 | 0.25806 | 0.21935 | 0.68015 |
INFLO | 9 | 0.25581 | 0.21698 | 0.17957 | 0.13676 | 0.28387 | 0.24650 | 0.67809 |
INFLO | 100 | 0.19767 | 0.15581 | 0.14610 | 0.10154 | 0.25723 | 0.21847 | 0.77703 |
COF | 15 | 0.20930 | 0.16804 | 0.15335 | 0.10916 | 0.21429 | 0.17328 | 0.74128 |
COF | 25 | 0.17442 | 0.13134 | 0.15056 | 0.10623 | 0.20968 | 0.16843 | 0.74518 |
COF | 39 | 0.15116 | 0.10687 | 0.16337 | 0.11971 | 0.25000 | 0.21086 | 0.73007 |
COF | 49 | 0.17442 | 0.13134 | 0.15753 | 0.11357 | 0.27027 | 0.23219 | 0.72122 |
Plots
Not normalized, duplicates
This version contains 21 attributes, 1742 objects, 87 outliers (4.99%)
Download raw algorithm results (15.0 MB) Download raw algorithm evaluation table (66.9 kB)
Best Parameters
The following table contains the best
(overall and per-method)
results for each method and evaluation measure (when the same score was achieved twice, only the smallest k is given).
The Maximum F1-Measure is complimentary in addition to the measures in the original publication.
Algorithm | k | P@n | Adj. P@n | AP | Adj. AP | Max-F1 | Adj. MF1 | ROC AUC |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
KNN | 1 | 0.21839 | 0.17730 | 0.18486 | 0.14201 | 0.23913 | 0.19913 | 0.76050 |
KNN | 2 | 0.19540 | 0.15311 | 0.17550 | 0.13216 | 0.25778 | 0.21876 | 0.76149 |
KNN | 39 | 0.18391 | 0.14101 | 0.14407 | 0.09907 | 0.28821 | 0.25079 | 0.73446 |
KNNW | 1 | 0.22989 | 0.18940 | 0.20373 | 0.16187 | 0.23952 | 0.19954 | 0.76349 |
KNNW | 3 | 0.21839 | 0.17730 | 0.19226 | 0.14980 | 0.24812 | 0.20860 | 0.77856 |
KNNW | 89 | 0.18391 | 0.14101 | 0.14553 | 0.10061 | 0.28444 | 0.24683 | 0.73882 |
LOF | 8 | 0.34483 | 0.31039 | 0.25828 | 0.21929 | 0.35294 | 0.31893 | 0.76748 |
LOF | 9 | 0.31034 | 0.27409 | 0.26347 | 0.22475 | 0.34177 | 0.30717 | 0.76827 |
LOF | 100 | 0.19540 | 0.15311 | 0.15772 | 0.11344 | 0.26380 | 0.22510 | 0.78543 |
SimplifiedLOF | 9 | 0.35632 | 0.32248 | 0.25964 | 0.22073 | 0.36111 | 0.32753 | 0.77793 |
SimplifiedLOF | 11 | 0.34483 | 0.31039 | 0.28179 | 0.24404 | 0.37419 | 0.34130 | 0.79012 |
SimplifiedLOF | 13 | 0.33333 | 0.29829 | 0.28033 | 0.24250 | 0.35000 | 0.31583 | 0.79819 |
LoOP | 11 | 0.34483 | 0.31039 | 0.26385 | 0.22515 | 0.36111 | 0.32753 | 0.77266 |
LoOP | 12 | 0.33333 | 0.29829 | 0.26690 | 0.22836 | 0.36025 | 0.32662 | 0.78050 |
LoOP | 13 | 0.32184 | 0.28619 | 0.27144 | 0.23314 | 0.36496 | 0.33158 | 0.77991 |
LDOF | 13 | 0.35632 | 0.32248 | 0.24400 | 0.20426 | 0.36158 | 0.32802 | 0.72577 |
LDOF | 16 | 0.35632 | 0.32248 | 0.25167 | 0.21233 | 0.36478 | 0.33139 | 0.72860 |
LDOF | 99 | 0.20690 | 0.16520 | 0.17103 | 0.12745 | 0.26582 | 0.22723 | 0.75539 |
ODIN | 13 | 0.22839 | 0.18782 | 0.14567 | 0.10076 | 0.22857 | 0.18802 | 0.71534 |
ODIN | 84 | 0.19540 | 0.15311 | 0.17697 | 0.13371 | 0.28296 | 0.24526 | 0.74981 |
ODIN | 100 | 0.19540 | 0.15311 | 0.18957 | 0.14697 | 0.27937 | 0.24148 | 0.75789 |
FastABOD | 4 | 0.24138 | 0.20150 | 0.18040 | 0.13732 | 0.25225 | 0.21294 | 0.77491 |
FastABOD | 5 | 0.24138 | 0.20150 | 0.19160 | 0.14910 | 0.26207 | 0.22328 | 0.76782 |
FastABOD | 9 | 0.25287 | 0.21360 | 0.18838 | 0.14572 | 0.25641 | 0.21732 | 0.76647 |
FastABOD | 12 | 0.24138 | 0.20150 | 0.18985 | 0.14726 | 0.27632 | 0.23827 | 0.76752 |
KDEOS | 18 | 0.18391 | 0.14101 | 0.12402 | 0.07798 | 0.19643 | 0.15419 | 0.74155 |
KDEOS | 96 | 0.13793 | 0.09261 | 0.13616 | 0.09074 | 0.21843 | 0.17734 | 0.75208 |
KDEOS | 97 | 0.13793 | 0.09261 | 0.13697 | 0.09160 | 0.22000 | 0.17900 | 0.75124 |
KDEOS | 100 | 0.14943 | 0.10471 | 0.13429 | 0.08878 | 0.23368 | 0.19339 | 0.75104 |
LDF | 6 | 0.21839 | 0.17730 | 0.21675 | 0.17557 | 0.26022 | 0.22133 | 0.74207 |
LDF | 8 | 0.25287 | 0.21360 | 0.21568 | 0.17445 | 0.26966 | 0.23127 | 0.75966 |
LDF | 99 | 0.22989 | 0.18940 | 0.16092 | 0.11681 | 0.25907 | 0.22012 | 0.78569 |
INFLO | 5 | 0.33333 | 0.29829 | 0.23683 | 0.19671 | 0.34940 | 0.31520 | 0.76169 |
INFLO | 6 | 0.34483 | 0.31039 | 0.26269 | 0.22394 | 0.36585 | 0.33252 | 0.74688 |
INFLO | 9 | 0.34483 | 0.31039 | 0.27902 | 0.24112 | 0.35556 | 0.32168 | 0.75425 |
COF | 9 | 0.28736 | 0.24989 | 0.21219 | 0.17078 | 0.28736 | 0.24989 | 0.75363 |
COF | 10 | 0.26437 | 0.22570 | 0.21576 | 0.17454 | 0.31183 | 0.27565 | 0.76772 |
COF | 11 | 0.27586 | 0.23780 | 0.22828 | 0.18772 | 0.30542 | 0.26891 | 0.76740 |
COF | 12 | 0.28736 | 0.24989 | 0.22445 | 0.18369 | 0.31250 | 0.27636 | 0.76287 |